Melanie Conroy Quoted in Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly: Gambling Recovery LLC Must Arbitrate Loss Recovery Act Claim
Excerpted from Massachusetts Lawyers Weekly
A company suing under Massachusetts’ centuries-old Loss Recovery Act to collect treble damages for other people’s gambling losses must arbitrate its claim if the gamblers themselves would have had to, a Business Litigation Session judge has ruled.
William M. Gantz of Boston, who represents the High 5 defendants, in an email called the court’s three grounds “complementary and standard analyses,” with estoppel and the derivative-claim finding the most important to the case.
Gantz said he doubts an arbitrator will even reach whether High 5’s games are gambling because the plaintiff “does not identify any actual person who is alleged to have gambled and lost,” which he said defeats its standing. In any event, “sweepstakes offered to promote a bona fide product or service are expressly authorized under Massachusetts law,” he said.
As for what comes next, Gantz predicted an appeal, as in other cases “brought by this group where their manufactured cases have been dismissed or sent to arbitration such as Ohio or Illinois.”
Thomas R. Murphy, a Salem attorney who has long chaired the amicus committee of the Massachusetts Academy of Trial Attorneys, called the ruling “a sound decision.”
“I don’t think it’s going anywhere,” he said. “It’s pretty bulletproof.”
The plaintiff’s case is more like a subrogation case than a qui tam action, Murphy noted, calling the wrongful death analogy “spot on.”
His advice to lawyers bringing a claim that derives from someone else’s transaction: “Look closely at what shoes you’re stepping into.”
Melanie A. Conroy, a Boston class action defense and business litigator, said arbitration fights have shifted. A decade ago, the flashpoints were unconscionability and notice; now that businesses have grown sophisticated about clickwrap agreements, the question is increasingly whom a clause can bind.
“You can tell that this is a little bit more of an emerging topic by how many centuries back the decision had to go to explore the rationale,” she said.
The LRA’s transfer of rights by operation of law is what kept the estoppel analysis from troubling her, Conroy said. Had the gamblers simply assigned their claims by contract, “I don’t know if you get the same result there,” she said. “To me, that would feel a lot more like a third party.”
If the ruling is vulnerable, she said, it may be on whether the LRA was meant to deter bad conduct through the public exposure of litigation. Sending the claims to private arbitration would then risk “clipping the wings of what this remedy was designed to provide” and present “a more meaty preemption question.”
Click here for the complete article by Kris Olson